Earlier today I was doing some online research for work, and came across some depressing news which I emailed out as follows:
From an article on sustainability and consumption:
I had the pleasure of being a keynote speaker with Yvon Chouinard of Patagonia at a "net impact" event late last year. He has done as much as any CEO to make sure that his company is respectful and protective of the environment. Yet in front of 100 net impacters, he said (I am paraphrasing), "I have talked to some serious scientists, and most of them believe we have passed the point of no return. We have no hope left to save the Earth."
Hopefully that is not 100% accurate. Unfortunately, it is actually possible that it could be true. The full article can be found here and presents a good case for reducing our consumption.
Feeling impossibly overwhelmed, I sent this out as an email to some of you (those on this blog who's emails I have in my EPG email account). Mom (Lakshmi) wrote back this response, pretty much capturing what I also was feeling:
What a challenge and it does look grim in a global economy down to our personal households. It seems our meager attempts, whatever they may be (vegetarian/vegan eating, recycling, shopping less...) are a little too late and certainly not nearly enough to address the issues of the 9 billion people arriving! We actually can't pat ourselves on the back---since even the most conscientious among us are still not doing much after all!
Coming home from work I got to process a bit, and here is how I would respond to my own hopelessness from earlier today. [Warning, significant God-talk and Bible references follow. This is my world-view with less translation than it sometimes receives and perhaps with a degree of assumed "kingdom theology." Hopefully the gist still comes across and if not I can add comments as needed.]
I think you are probably right - in the end it probably will take war(s) to really wake us up to the enormity of the problem and effect the significant change in our lifestyles as well as the very infrastructure of our society. Kira and I are wearing ourselves out just trying to get our edible landscape (garden) going, and while I think it is a good way to be spending our energy you are right, it is all a drop in the bucket compared to the magnitude of the problem. (I do however think we live in a democratic economy - how I spend my dollars is my economic vote. And, as we learned in Florida, every vote counts.... at least half! But I agree, my individual actions seem inconsequential in comparison to the overwhelmingly "obese" infrastructure I live in.)
It's funny, Kira and I were visiting this church yesterday and the pastor was preaching from Revelation, talking about these images of God's final, sovereign, good reign. The fullness of God's kingdom come. God's perfect reign of peace, wisdom, holiness, and love over all creation finally come to fulfillment. And his application was to topics of worry - worrying about your money, or your job, or whatever. The message was "God is in control." A fine message. But if you take the book of Revelation as a whole, it is speaking to the epic struggle of Good versus Evil. God versus Satan. Who will triumph? What is really happening in our world? To all appearances, God seems many times absent. But Revelation tells a different story. It tells a story of God's victory and paints a beautiful picture of God's final reign. The larger message of Revelation is not necessarily "God cares about your provisions, your dented car, your mortgage bill, etc." (though I believe God does care about those things). I think the larger message of Revelation is "People of God: when the story of the world around you looks desperately hopeless, remember that God is telling a different story. A story of hope and redemption and healing and God's kingdom come. And God's story is ultimately the one that will prevail." [Remember Revelation was written before Christianity was the religion of the empire, while Christians weren't exactly popular and the future for the people of God probably looked pretty hopeless.]
So I think it takes a Revelation perspective to look the enormous problem laid before us squarely in the eyes and say "This story of hopelessness is not going to determine my actions. I am going to live believing a different story from the one I see. Believing that God's kingdom will come, and that - ushered in through Jesus - God's kingdom is coming now, today." And because God's kingdom is coming now, today, we are free as the people of God to prophetically build gardens and serve the poor and research the cure for AIDS and build community and seek to help usher in any of the other bazillion facets of God's kingdom come.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
Andy ~
I dig it. It's like Mother Theresa said: "God didn't ask me to be successful, God asked me to be faithful."
On the other hand, Derrick Jensen, in Endgame (vols. 1 & 2), his books that changed my life remarks at how we life-loving critters of society don't look like we're really playing it to win. In other words - our faithfulness/ hope in the kingdom of God to manifest itself - is like the abused wife knowing that God will restore peace on earth someday while she gets bludgeoned, and so in good faith yelps "I love you, please stop!"
Jensen, who was abused as a child, would make the case that a psychotic husband is like a psychotic culture - it's beyond reason, rationale, and good faith efforts to vote right, do humanure, rock permaculture gardens, and yelp for a change. These yelps (drops in the bucket) to stop, would work if you were dealing with somebody who wasn't actually suffering from a virtually incurable psychosis (if I remember right from Jensen's data, there aren't any cases of a chronic wife-beater ever being reformed. It's a disease, like AIDS, a deadly twist in humanity).
What looks like playing to win is the wife (us) realizing that she's dealing with somebody who has an incurable psychosis (civilization), who won't stop until she's dead (civilization), and needs to be beaten the only way he can be: with physical force. So she (we) wait til the guy's asleep (civilization's numerous vulnerabilities resulting from our society running on computers, bureaucracy, and laws instead of living things. for example, the squat I'm sitting in right now) and we shoot him in the head.
I'm fine with hoping, but when dealing with a psychotic entity, it's time to play to win, not to hope. If someone came into your house and locked all the doors, said he was going to kill Pace and Satya and gas the house, and you had a gun, don't tell me you wouldn't use it because of God's story being in control! This is self defense!
This is what I'm talking about. Self defense. God's story being the ultimate one is fine, but it's WE who may be the wrath of God that he wants to visit, in addition to the love.
Hey Gabe,
Thanks for challenging me on this. Here's where I think I am at right now regarding what you are saying:
1) I don't think the proverbial "killer threating my kids" has entered the house yet. In other words, I do not think we are yet at a point of no return with respect to the environment. Have we done damage that cannot be reversed in a few decades? Yes. Have we completely dismantled our ecosystems yet? I don't think so. Perhaps civilization is beyond reform and no good change will ever come. But I have not yet reached that conclusion nor do I tihnk the time has come to pose that question. Moreover, I look at some of the good things happening in Europe from a policy perspective and I have to wonder if civilization is indeed beyond reform as you claim it to be.
2) I would be curious to hear what shooting civilization in the head would look like. Anarchy? Revolution? What would come of it? What would be born out of it? And most importantly: why do you think it would be fundamentally different from any of the current systems (or anarchies) found throughout the world today? People made this system we live in. It is not an alien oppression; it is an oppression of our own making.
3) I think there may be one point I can clarify from what I was saying before. I think taking part in the unfolding of the kingdom of God means revolution. Loving, non-violent, impossible-to-subdue revolution. I don't know what that looks like right now. I think us learning how to garden in our back yard is part of a grounding, but it is not the end of the process. I just don't happen to know what the next step looks like right now (which, by the way, is why I appreciate your challenges, even through I may disagree).
Post a Comment